diff --git a/setup-scripts/health-checker.py b/setup-scripts/health-checker.py
index 3b7094b1..2e3960ad 100755
--- a/setup-scripts/health-checker.py
+++ b/setup-scripts/health-checker.py
@@ -290,8 +290,10 @@ async def check_alerts():
         force_notify = True
     if num_error_alerts > 0:
         message += "{} Error Alerts found! ".format(num_error_alerts)
-        force_notify = num_error_alerts > num_siafile_alerts
 
+    # Subtract out the siafile alerts from the warning alerts since we announce
+    # them separately
+    num_warning_alerts -= num_siafile_alerts
     message += "{} Warning Alerts found. ".format(num_warning_alerts)
     message += "{} SiaFiles with bad health found. ".format(num_siafile_alerts)